Building Review

Review No:1

B26-2861_2025-05-13_1st Review Steven Raney, CASp. CBO, MCP

Resubmittals: Please provide a comprehensive resubmittal through the ePlan portal for review. Include an annotated copy of these comments and clearly explain revision locations with sheet/drawing numbers. Identify revisions with clouding and delta markers. Text can be copied/pasted from the Application Status page into text editors.

Confirm: Changes have been made in addition to those resulting from review comments? Yes / No (circle or delete).

If yes, briefly describe the changes and locations on the documents:

__________________________________________________________________________________________________.

Building Review Comments

ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS:

A1. Sheet T1-Revise the code references on the cover sheet to include the following missing codes: 2025 California Wildland Urban Interface Code, 2025 California Existing Building Code (CEBC), and 2025 California Historical Building Code (CHBC).

A2. Sheet T1- Specify the proposed septic tank size, material, and show setbacks to South property line and the proposed SFR. Clarify the the construction, size, and number of leach fields provided to coordinate with Environmental Health approval.

A3. Sheet T-1- Clarify if the propane tank is new or existing. Note the size and show the setbacks from the tank to the adjacent property lines and structures. Show the underground gas line run including the type of pipe and size to the SFR.

A4. Sheet T-1- Clarify the electrical connection to the well pump. Show new or existing connections including underground connections from the electrical service to the well.

A5. Sheet T-1- The Architectural Designer of Record is required to sign all Architectural plan sheets per the CA Business and Professions code.

A6. Sheet T-1- Show the location of the exterior water heater and condenser on the site plan to coordinate with the MEP plan.

A7. Sheet T-1- Clarify what the electrical service is for the SFR attached to the container. The MEP plan shows a separate PV and ESS system, but is there a grid connected service? There is a 200A main show on the site plan, is this connecting to the container and new SFR?

A8. Sheet A1- Provide manufacturer documentation for the proposed standing seam metal roof assembly. Specify the roof panel manufacturer, product name, color/finish, ICC-ESR or approved listing/report, underlayment type, and installation requirements to verify the complete roof assembly is Class A. The plans shall show that the roof covering, underlayment, and installation comply with CRC R337.5 for WUI construction and CRC R902 for roof classification.

A9. Sheet A1- Provide foundation and anchorage details for the proposed detached cargo container workshop/utility room. The plans show the container supported on a gravel base only; however, the structure contains electrical panels, PV equipment, ESS equipment, and permanent utility connections. Provide an approved permanent foundation/anchorage system designed to resist gravity, wind, and seismic loads and to prevent movement, sliding, overturning, or displacement of the container and attached utility systems. Foundation and anchorage details shall be designed for the site conditions and shall show footing size, embedment, reinforcement, anchor type/spacing, connection to the container frame, and load path to the supporting soils. Comply with CRC R301.1, R401.1, R403.1, R403.1.2, CBC 1604, CBC 1613, CBC 1808/1809, and CEC 110.3(B) and 110.13(A).

A10. Sheet A2- Provide underfloor access to the crawl space. The plans show a raised floor/crawl space condition but do not identify the required access opening. Show the location, size, and construction of the underfloor access opening. Access through the floor shall be 18" x 24" minimum, and access through a perimeter wall shall be 16" x 24" minimum. Comply with CRC R408.4.

A11. Sheet A3- Revise all WUI notes and code references to the 2025 California Wildland-Urban Interface Code, Title 24, Part 7. CBC Chapter 7A and CRC R337 are no longer the correct references for the 2025 code cycle.

A12. Sheet A3- Provide a vapor retarder as required for the unvented cathedral ceiling/roof assembly. The Energy Compliance documents show R-38 spray foam insulation; however, the plans do not identify the required vapor retarder. Revise the roof assembly notes to show compliance with CRC R806.5.

A13. Sheet A4- Provide Aging-in-Place notes and details on the plans for the new dwelling. At least one bathroom shall be provided with grab bar reinforcement at the water closet, shower, bathtub, or combination tub/shower as applicable. Reinforcement shall be 2x8 nominal minimum or approved equivalent, located between 32" and 39-1/4" above the finished floor, and installed in the locations required by CRC R328.1.1. Provide documentation identifying the grab bar reinforcement locations in the operation and maintenance manual per CRC R328.1.1.1. Electrical receptacle outlets, switches, and controls intended for occupant use shall be installed no more than 48" to the top of the outlet box and not less than 15" to the bottom of the outlet box above the finished floor per CRC R328.1.2. Doorbell buttons or controls, where installed, shall not exceed 48" above the exterior floor or landing measured to the top of the assembly per CRC R328.1.4.

A14. Sheet A-5- Revise the door schedule to show compliance with CRC R328.1.3. At least one bedroom and one bathroom on the entry level shall provide a doorway with a net clear opening of not less than 32", measured with the door positioned 90 degrees from the closed position. The door schedule currently shows 32" interior doors; provide the required net clear opening or revise the required bedroom and bathroom doors to a size that provides the minimum 32" net clear opening.

ENERGY COMMENTS:

En1. Sheet A-4-Provide BESS-ready prewiring and panel requirements per Energy Code 150.0(s). The Energy Compliance documents show all-electric appliances, except the cooktop fuel source has not been clarified. Revise the electrical plans to show the required BESS-ready provisions, including the required backed-up load circuits, raceway/interconnection provisions, panel labeling, and minimum 225 amp main panel busbar rating where applicable. Coordinate with the Energy Compliance documents and clarify whether the cooktop is gas or electric.

GREEN BUILDING COMMENTS:

GB1. No comment at this time.

MECHANICAL COMMENTS:

M1. Sheet A4- Kitchen exhaust- For a 1155 sf dwelling with an electric cooktop/range, the kitchen range hood shall provide 110 cfm minimum per Energy Code Table 150.0-G. If a gas cooktop/range is proposed, revise the Energy Compliance documents and show the required kitchen range hood at 250 cfm minimum per Energy Code Table 150.0-G.

M2. Sheet A4- Show the location of the minimum 60 cfm IAQ fan on the mechanical/electrical plans and coordinate with the Energy Compliance documents. Identify the fan as continuous or demand controlled as applicable, and show the required controls, airflow rate, and duct termination.

PLUMBING COMMENTS:

P1. Sheet A4- Clarify the proposed fuel source for the dwelling. The MEP plans show a propane tank connection, while the Energy Compliance documents indicate all-electric appliances. Revise the plans for consistency. If propane is not proposed, remove the propane tank and gas piping notes. If propane is proposed, revise the Energy Compliance documents and clarify whether the cooktop is gas or electric.

P2. If propane is provided to the new SFR, add this note to the site plan and MEP plan , and provide a seismic valve for the propane line into the SFR. “New gas piping systems, replacement gas piping systems, and new or replacement gas meter installations, shall have a listed and approved earthquake-actuated gas shutoff valve (sized for the BTU demand of the entire gas system) installed just prior to the meter connection or connection to a propane tank, prior to the release of utilities. [SCC 12.10.235(B)]?

P3. Sheet A-4- Provide a listed exterior enclosure for the proposed ProTerra Hybrid 50-gallon heat pump water heater. Install the water heater and enclosure per the manufacturer’s listing and installation instructions.

ELECTRICAL COMMENTS:

E1. Sheet A4-Please calculate the electrical demand. Provide a sub-panel schedule for the proposed SFR to justify all electrical appliance loads. You may find the following forms useful:

EVCS Electrical Load Calculation Single-Family - PLG290

E2. All newly constructed commercial and residential buildings that have electrically supplied systems shall provide a concrete encased grounding electrode per CEC 250.52(A)(3) to serve as the grounding means for the electrical system. [SCC 12.10.240(B)]

E3. Sheet T-1- Clarify what the electrical service is for the SFR attached to the container. The MEP plan shows a separate PV and ESS system, but is there a grid connected service? There is a 200A main show on the site plan, is this connecting to the container and new SFR?

E4. Sheet A4- Provide smoke alarm and carbon monoxide alarm locations on the electrical/life safety plan. Smoke alarms shall be provided in each sleeping room, outside each separate sleeping area in the immediate vicinity of the bedrooms, and on each story of the dwelling per CRC R314. Carbon monoxide alarms shall be provided outside each separate sleeping area in the immediate vicinity of the bedrooms and on each story of the dwelling where required per CRC R315. Show alarms interconnected with primary power and battery backup as required.

STRUCTURAL COMMENTS:

S1. Sheet T1.1- The Registered Design Professional of Record is the Civil Engineer, not the Property Owner. Please revise the Special Inspection statement to reflect this. The Registered Design Professional is required to complete the balance of the PLG 200 special Inspections form, and the Contractor is also required to sign it.

S2. Sheet S-1- Provide structural plans for the wood patio deck. The current structural pages show this is to be designed by others.

S3. Sheet S-1- Provide a fastening schedule on the plans. The fastening schedule may be provided on the architectural or structural plans and shall include the applicable framing, sheathing, blocking, sole plate, top plate, roof, floor, wall, and connection fastening requirements per CRC Table R602.3(1).

S4. Provide the PLG-300 form completed by the Geotech Engineer accepting the foundation plan as incorporating the requirements of the soils report into the structural design.

Structural Calculations

SC1. Update the structural calculations and roof framing design to include the site-specific snow load. The ASCE Hazard Tool shows Pg = 28 psf ground snow load for the project site using ASCE 7-22. Revise the snow load calculations, roof load combinations, roof framing design, and structural plans as necessary to show compliance with the 2025 CRC/CBC and ASCE 7-22.

SC2. Provide complete structural calculations for the proposed residence. The submitted calculation packet appears limited to roof framing and lateral analysis and does not include foundation/footing calculations, floor framing calculations, roof rafter calculations, or beam/header calculations. Revise the structural calculations and plans to provide a complete gravity and lateral design, including footing sizes, foundation reinforcing, floor framing, roof framing, beams/headers, load paths, and all applicable 2025 CRC/CBC and ASCE 7-22 design loads.

Fire Comments

1.) Provide code references to site plan that include California WUI Code.

  1. Plans shall show building meets all requirements of the California WUI Code 2025.

2.) Project exists within a Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone. Identify if project is not subject to a fire protection plan and vegetation management plan from the County of Santa Cruz.

3.) Deferred submittals include fire hydrant, tank, and sprinkler installations, identify compliance with County of Santa Cruz FP0-017 - Fire Hydrant Markings, FP0-020 – Construction Site and Fire Safety, FP0-006 – Private Water Systems for 13D.

4.) Identify if kitchen range hood falls under the requirement of NFPA 17 or 17A.

5.) Identify on plans the design professional’s current registration and license.

6.) Identify on plans that the grade does not exceeding 15% and not being in excess of 20%, per FPO – 012 of the County of Santa Cruz FD.

7.) Roadway is required to be 12 to 18 feet in width per FPO – 012 of the County of Santa Cruz.

8.) Identify that there is a 10-foot horizontal clearance from roadways of combustible vegetation, per FPO -012 of the County of Santa Cruz.

9.) Identify on plans that the project in question is in compliance with FPO – 014 of the County of Santa Cruz.

10.) Plans Indicate that the proposed inside turning radius is not in compliance with FPO – 015, that requires a 36’ distance from the inside of the turnaround to the outside.

11.) Identify on plans that, addressing shall be identified with minimum four-inch (4”) high numbers, with a minimum one-half inch (1/2”) stroke, as per FP0-016 per the County of Santa Cruz.

12.) Plans identify an existing on site water tank to be used for fire protection. Identify on plans that the tank will be in compliance with FP0-006 & FP0-007 of the County of Santa Cruz, specifically system design requirements, water supply, & pump system.

  1. Identify that existing underground complies with technical policy.
  2. Identify appropriate turnout area for onsite water tank.
  3. Provide manufacturers with specifications of existing water tank if available.

13.) For proposed fire hydrant installation provide installation requirements that align with FPO-007 Fire Department Connection to a fire hydrant.

Installation must comply with page 6-9 of the policy.

Resubmittal Info:Application Status, ePlan User Guide, and ePlan Videos.

Reviews: Additional fees are added to permits for comments leading to a 3rd review.

Questions:Resubmittals are required for reviews. BuildingReview questions can be emailed to Steve Raney (sraney@4leafinc.com) Matt Dingman (mdingman@4leafinc.com)

Review No:2

B26-2861_2026-09-14_Updated 2nd Review by Matt Dingman & Steven Raney, CASp. CBO, MCP

Resubmittals: Please provide a comprehensive resubmittal through the ePlan portal for review. Include an annotated copy of these comments and clearly explain revision locations with sheet/drawing numbers. Identify revisions with clouding and delta markers. Text can be copied/pasted from the Application Status page into text editors.

Confirm: Changes have been made in addition to those resulting from review comments? Yes / No (circle or delete).

If yes, briefly describe the changes and locations on the documents:

__________________________________________________________________________________________________.

Building Review Comments

ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS:

A1. Completed

A2. Completed

A3. Completed

A4. Completed

A5. Completed

A6. Completed

A7. Completed

A8. Completed

A9. Completed

A10. Completed

A11. Completed

A12. Completed

A13. Completed

A14. Completed

ENERGY COMMENTS:

En1. Completed

GREEN BUILDING COMMENTS:

GB1. No comment at this time.

MECHANICAL COMMENTS:

M1. Completed

M2. Completed

PLUMBING COMMENTS:

P1. Completed

P2. Completed

P3. PC2 9/3/26-The plans continue to show the ProTerra Hybrid 50-gallon water heater installed outdoors without an enclosure. Provide an exterior enclosure for the water heater, or provide an alternate exterior listed water heater without installing it in an enclosure.

ELECTRICAL COMMENTS:

E1. Completed

E2. Completed

E3. Completed

E4. Completed

STRUCTURAL COMMENTS:

S1. PC2 9/3/26-Revise and complete the PLG-240 Special Inspections form on Sheet T1.1. The Civil Engineer providing the structural design shall be identified and sign as the Registered Design Professional in Responsible Charge. If no structural special inspections are required for the proposed design, none need to be specified; however, the PLG-240 form must still be fully completed, signed by all required parties, and included in the plan set per County requirements. Coordinate with the Geotechnical Engineer and identify the applicable soils inspections/testing as Continuous or Periodic, as required. Sheet T1.1- The Registered Design Professional of Record is the Civil Engineer, not the Property Owner. Please revise the Special Inspection statement to reflect this. The Registered Design Professional is required to complete the balance of the PLG 240 special Inspections form, and the Contractor is also required to sign it.

S2. Completed

S3. PC 9/3/26-The fastening schedule applies to the overall residential construction, including structural framing as well as items such as gypsum board, exterior lath, siding, and other applicable construction. If the Civil Engineer does not include the complete fastening schedule on the structural plans, it may be provided on the architectural plans. Provide or reference the applicable fastening requirements of 2025 CRC Table R602.3(1). Sheet S-1- Provide a fastening schedule on the plans. The fastening schedule may be provided on the architectural or structural plans and shall include the applicable framing, sheathing, blocking, sole plate, top plate, roof, floor, wall, and connection fastening requirements per CRC Table R602.3(1).

S4. PC2 9/3/26- This is a County requirement and must be completed on the PLG-300 Consultant Plan Review form by the Geotechnical Engineer. The County requires the Geotechnical Engineer to review the final plans for conformance with the geotechnical report recommendations. Coordination may be handled by the architectural designer, owner-builder, or other project representative; this comment is not assigning that coordination responsibility to the Civil Engineer. Please have the Geotech Engineer sign and stamp the form. Provide the PLG-300 form completed by the Geotech Engineer accepting the foundation plan as incorporating the requirements of the soils report into the structural design.

Structural Calculations

SC1. PC2 9/3/26- The project is subject to the 2025 CBC/CRC, effective January 1, 2026, which uses ASCE 7-22. Snow load under ASCE 7-22 is site-specific. The ASCE Hazard Tool shows a ground snow load, Pg = 28 psf, for this project site. Revise the structural design using the site-specific ground snow load and determine the applicable roof snow load in accordance with ASCE 7-22. The 28 psf value is the ground snow load, not a required 28 psf uniform roof load. The ASCE Hazard Tool may be accessed here www.ascehazardtool.org. Santa Cruz County confirms that the 2025 California Building Standards Code became effective January 1, 2026. Update the structural calculations and roof framing design to include the site-specific snow load. The ASCE Hazard Tool shows Pg = 28 psf ground snow load for the project site using ASCE 7-22. Revise the snow load calculations, roof load combinations, roof framing design, and structural plans as necessary to show compliance with the 2025 CRC/CBC and ASCE 7-22.

SC2. PC2 9/3/26-Clarify on the structural plans which portions of the structure are designed prescriptively under the 2025 CRC and which portions are engineered. For prescriptive elements, identify the applicable CRC table/section and design criteria on the plans. Provide calculations for structural elements that are engineered or outside the prescriptive provisions of the CRC. Coordinate the structural design with the revised snow load required by SC1. Provide complete structural calculations for the proposed residence. The submitted calculation packet appears limited to roof framing and lateral analysis and does not include foundation/footing calculations, floor framing calculations, roof rafter calculations, or beam/header calculations. Revise the structural calculations and plans to provide a complete gravity and lateral design, including footing sizes, foundation reinforcing, floor framing, roof framing, beams/headers, load paths, and all applicable 2025 CRC/CBC and ASCE 7-22 design loads.

Fire Comments

1.) Project exists within a Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone. Per County of Santa Cruz Fire Code plans must state what is provided below and the project is required to adhere to the requirements stated below.

  1. 304.1.3—Vegetation. Weeds, grass, vines or other growth that is capable of being ignited and endangering property, shall be cut down and removed by the owner or occupant of the premises. Vegetation clearance requirements in urban-wildland interface areas shall be maintained around and adjacent to buildings and structures. A firebreak shall be made by removing and clearing away, for a distance of not less than 30 feet (9144 mm) on each side of the building or structure or to the property line, whichever is nearer, all flammable vegetation or other combustible growth. This does not apply to single specimens of trees or other vegetation that is well-pruned and maintained so as to effectively manage fuels and not form a means of rapidly transmitting fire from other nearby vegetation to any building or structure.
  2. When required by state law, or local ordinance, rule or regulation, an additional fire protection zone or firebreak may be made by removing all brush, flammable vegetation, or combustible growth that is located within 100 feet (30,480 mm) from the building or structure or to the property line. This section does not prevent an insurance company that insures a building or structure from requiring the owner of the building or structure to maintain a firebreak of more than 100 feet (30,480 mm) around the building or structure. Grass and other vegetation located more than 30 feet (9144 mm) from the building or structure and less than 18 inches (457 mm) in height above the ground may be maintained where necessary to stabilize the soil and prevent erosion. This does not apply to single specimens of trees or other vegetation that is well-pruned and maintained so as to effectively manage fuels and not form a means of rapidly transmitting fire from other nearby vegetation to a dwelling or structure.
  3. Vegetation clearance requirements in the wildland-urban interface areas shall be in accordance with Part 7 of Title 24 California Code of Regulations (California Wildland-Urban Interface Code).

2.) Plans shall state: Provide an automatic filling device. Pump to automatically activate to maintain water storage tank at a minimum capacity of 10,000 gallons. If low water cut-off switch is installed, it shall be set to activate no higher than 6" above centerline of suction discharge pipe.

3.) While certain jurisdictions may allow for an owner builder declaration, CA Business and Professions Code Section 19825. Architectural set of plans require a professional license. Please provide County of Santa Cruz Owner Builder Declaration or something similar.

4.) Plans identify an existing on site water tank to be used for fire protection. Identify on plans that the tank will have appropriate turnout area for on-site water tank.

Resubmittal Info:Application Status, ePlan User Guide, and ePlan Videos.

Reviews: Additional fees are added to permits for comments leading to a 3rd review.

Questions:Resubmittals are required for reviews. BuildingReview questions can be emailed to Steve Raney (sraney@4leafinc.com).

Questions ab